Growing hospice care brings concerns about misuse
United States (KaiserHealth) – As she surveyed patients’ charts, Nancy Romeo, a medical review auditor at a hospice company, was surprised by the resilience of those supposedly near death.
One patient admitted to hospice care in 2002 was still healthy enough in 2007 to stroll around his yard at home, she found. Another patient received hospice care for four years before the company for which Romeo worked, SouthernCare, determined she was not dying. “I looked at charts every day, and almost every chart was inappropriate,” said Romeo, a nurse.
Nancy Romeo looks over files in the office of her lawyer Henry Frohsin on Thursday, Feb. 17, 2011, in Birmingham, AL.
In 2007, she filed a whistleblower lawsuit against SouthernCare claiming that the company had fraudulently enrolled patients in hospice. Eventually, the government obtained a $24.7 million settlement in the case. SouthernCare, based in Birmingham, AL, and one of the nation’s largest for-profit hospice companies, admitted no wrongdoing, and officials declined comment for this article.
Over the 28 years that Medicare has reimbursed providers for hospice services, it has been praised for giving critical medical and emotional support to dying patients and their families. When properly used – that is, at the very end of life – hospice care also has saved the government money. Providing dying patients with palliative care in their own homes, or in a hospice facility or nursing home, is far less expensive than continuing to order up futile medical treatments, studies have shown.
Indeed, advocates say more patients should be receiving hospice services earlier in the course of their illness. The median time spent in hospice care now is just 17 days.
But as hospice has moved into the mainstream – it is now serving 1.1 million Medicare patients a year – concerns about excessive costs and misuse have mounted.
Four in 10 Medicare beneficiaries now use the hospice benefit before they die. Patients agree to forgo treatments aimed at prolonging their lives, but can receive pain-relieving medication to ease the symptoms of a terminal illness, as well as attention from nurses, social workers and others.
Medicare’s bill for hospice care rose to more than $12 billion in 2009 from $2.9 billion in 2000. Although the benefit is intended for patients who have no more than six months to live,’ percent now receive hospice services for longer, according to the Medicare Payment Advisory Commission, or MedPAC, an independent congressional oversight panel. In 2009, 10 percent of patients remained in hospice beyond seven months. Medicare pays a flat fee ranging from $147 to $856 a day, depending on the level of care, whether a hospice actually provides services or not.
Financial Incentives
A primary concern of MedPAC is that this payment method encourages hospices to seek out patients likely to live longer. For-profit hospices in particular tend to have longer-staying patients, studies have shown.
“The financial incentives do in fact dictate behavior,” said Eugene Goldenberg, a research analyst for BB&T Capital Markets who follows the hospice industry. “It’s a lucrative business, at least under the current reimbursement system.”
In response, Medicare has adopted a restriction: It won’t pay for hospice beyond six months unless a physician or nurse practitioner visits the patient and attests that his or her condition is still terminal. But this requirement, part of the health care law passed last year, has provoked a backlash.
Hospice operators say sending a doctor or nurse practitioner out to see every patient at the six-month mark is too expensive. Presently, most hospices rely on registered nurses to see patients and then relay information back to the office.
“This face-to-face visit is a way to limit the length of people staying on hospice, and it probably will increase the number of people who get discharged,” said Dr. David Casarett, an associate professor of medicine at the University of Pennsylvania and chief medical officer at the university’s Philadelphia-based hospice. “But will we be discharging the right people? I’m not sure.”
But given the financial and political pressures facing Medicare, government officials are concerned that hospice care may be misused. The inspector general of the Department of Health and Human Services looked at one fast-growing segment – hospice patients in nursing homes – and found hospices routinely failed to document that those patients belonged in a hospice or that they were getting the care to which they were entitled. The inspector general is now investigating unusual patterns of hospice stays.
Evidence produced in a series of lawsuits, too, suggests that hospices may need more careful oversight.
A regional vice president at Trinity Hospice, a now-defunct chain based in Texas, “strongly encouraged” employees to “find a way” to keep patients as long as possible, according to a 2005 internal report uncovered in a whistleblower lawsuit.
In 2006, the government obtained a $12.9 million settlement from another national chain, Odyssey Healthcare, after a former manager there said she was fired for trying to get the company to discharge patients who did not meet Medicare’s eligibility rules.
Both companies settled the cases out of court and did not admit wrongdoing. Odyssey was subsequently bought by Gentiva Health Services, and a company spokesman had no comment on the settlement.
Dementia’s Unpredictability
One of the main reasons for longer hospice stays is the increasing prevalence of patients with diseases, like dementia, that follow sometimes unpredictable paths. For instance, Alzheimer’s patients are three times more likely than cancer patients to stay in hospice beyond six months, MedPAC data show.
In 2009, Duane Chirhart, a retired airline pilot, questioned the cost of his aunt’s hospice care while she was in a nursing home in Minnesota. For more than two years, the nursing home had been taking care of most of her needs. At the same time, a hospice company billed Medicare $4,252 a month for its services, which included short visits by outside nurses.
“The employees who visited her were really caring people,” he said, “but there only were four or five hours a month when they were actually there.” Chirhart canceled the hospice service. His aunt, who has Alzheimer’s, is now 88 and still alive.
When the humorist Art Buchwald went into a hospice in February 2006, he expected to die within weeks of kidney failure. But his kidneys kept working, and Buchwald made national news when he quit hospice after five months. He died the following year.
To allow for greater flexibility, Congress ended the strict seven-month time limit imposed when the benefit was created. Now hospice care can continue indefinitely so long as the hospice said the patient is still likely to die within six months.
“To some degree, the growth in the number of beneficiaries and the duration of stays is the result of conscious policy changes,” said Jonathan Blum, deputy administrator of the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services.
Alexander Horvath, who is 85 and has dementia, is in his eighth month of care provided by the Jewish Social Service Agency Hospice, a nonprofit in Rockville, MD. His wife, Jacqueline, believes that he is receiving excellent, cost-effective care. The hospice has taken steps to prevent bedsores, for instance, by replacing his mattresses with special ones that help keep lesions from developing. “I want him to be as happy and comfortable as long as he possibly can be,” she said.
But the profit motive in hospice has become a greater concern as for-profits hospices have expanded. They now account for half of Medicare certified hospices. A study in the Journal of the American Medical Association published in February found 6.9 percent of patients tended by for-profit hospice providers remained for more than a year, while 2 percent of those in nonprofits did.
“Objectively if patients are in hospice more than a year, it kind of suggests that based on current hospice eligibility criteria they have been enrolled too early in the course of their terminal illness,” said Dr. Melissa Wachterman, the study’s lead author.
J. Donald Schumacher, president of the National Hospice and Palliative Care Organization, based in Alexandria, VA., said longer stays are a good development, because the full benefit of hospice can’t be realized in just the final days of life. He said a hospice’s ownership type does not influence the nature of care provided, and credits hospices for enrolling patients earlier in their declines. “Hospices have gotten better and more sophisticated in marketing their services to patients whose illness are moving from chronic disease into terminal illness,” Schumacher said.
But some fear that hospice companies have become too aggressive. “There are rival companies trying to get people to sign up for who will care for them until they die,” said Lloyd Peeples, an assistant U.S. attorney who led the government’s case against SouthernCare. “I had no idea there were companies fighting over patients, just like telephone companies fighting over whether to sell you an iPhone or a Blackberry.”
jrau@kff.org
– Provided by Kaiser Health News.
View full post on Health Treatment Stories
Botox for excessive sweating may interfere with texting.
Rochester, MN, United States (AHN) – A 17-year-old girl, an admitted champ at texting, could not text as well following Botox injections for excessive sweating on her palms, according to a case study published in the Archives of Dermatology.
Since Botox injections have been linked to muscle weakness, doctors said this is a distinct possibility. The teen was treated at Mayo Clinic, in Rochester, MN.
The case raises awareness of the potential risks of Botox for hyperhidrosis, or excessive sweating, and the possible side effects that may result from injections. The condition can make it difficult to perform certain tasks that require dexterity, so treatments are necessary.
Prescriptions antiperspirants are usually the first course of treatment, and if the patient does not respond, Botox is another option. But, as this incident shows, there may be side effects.
View full post on Health Treatment Stories
Johnson & Johnson halts production of drug-coated heart stents
Bridgewater, NJ, United States (AHN) – Consumer care products manufacturer Johnson & Johnson said it would halt the production of drug-coated heath stents by the year end.
The move, announced by the firm on Wednesday, is expected to create a vacuum in the $4-billion market amid concerns over the use of stents on some patients.
Cordis Corporation, a Johnson & Johnson subsidiary, will likely shed 900 to 1,000 jobs this year and the firm is expected to take a $500 million to $600 million restructuring charge this quarter.
The decision to stop making the drug-coated heart stents is both caused by weaker sales and questions over the necessity of the device for some patients. In 2010, Cordis’ global sales of the heart stents plummeted to $627 million from $2.6 billion in 2006.
Recent research indicate that the stent – a small device inserted through blood vessels to keep arteries open in the heart, is overused by doctors. New drugs that are cheaper, safer and more effective for some patients are more effective ways for many cardiovascular sufferers to avoid heart attacks or strokes.
With Cordis’ move, the dwindling heart stent market would be left to three remaining companies.
Seth Fischer, Cordia chairman worldwide, also blamed an appellate court’s decision last week that favored unlicensed competition for eroding the firm’s pricing, sales and market share.
The 900 to 1,000 jobs to be lost are at Cordis’ facilities in Puerto Rico and Ireland.
Cordis observed its 50 years of being a leader in the development and production of breakthrough treatments for cardiovascular ailments in 2009. From a garage in Miami, Florida, Cordis has grown to a global giant with sales of $3.1 billion in 2008. About 50 percent of the sales were outside the U.S.
Cordis introduced in the 1990s the heart stent, which was named one of the Top 30 Innovations of the Last 30 Years by the Wharton Business Schools and PBS’ Nightly Business Report.
View full post on Health Treatment Stories
Male manicure sparks discrimination suit, court stops salon from charging men more
Landover, MD, United States (AHN) – A Maryland nail salon is facing a gender discrimination lawsuit for charging male customers more than its female clients.
Norris Sydnor III of Mitchellville is seeking $200,000 in damages from the Rich’s Nail Salon in Landover after he was charged with $10 for a manicure in December.
The salon charges female customer $9 for the same service. Its brochure indicates the cost of nail filing, shaping, cuticle trimming and polishing as $9 for women and $10 for men. Other services are also priced $1 or $2 higher for male customers.
A court ordered Wednesday the salon to stop overcharging men for the meantime, according to Sydnor’s attorney, Jimmy Bell. The hearing of the case starts on July 21.
Rich’s Nail Salon has pulled its brochure and declined to comment.
Bell warned other salon’s charging men more than women to stop doing so.
View full post on Consumer Issue Stories
Two-day charity recreational fishing tourney kicks off in Massachusetts
A two-day recreational fishing tournament that will benefit the Schwartz Center for Children kicked off just after midnight Friday and will continue Saturday in New Bedford. The Dartmouth-based Schwartz Center for Children is a non-profit organization that cares for the developmentally disabled.
View full post on Lifestyle And Leisure Stories
Re-cycling in Sacramento: Capital city starts bike-sharing program
Sacramento isn’t ready to give nearby Davis, California, a run for its status as the so-called “bicycle capital of the world,” but leaders here are starting a small bike-friendly program in the heart of the state capital.
View full post on Lifestyle And Leisure Stories
Loans- U.S. expands faster airport screening process to busiest airports
- Airbus A380 wings to have checks for cracks
- Talks continue between MTA, New York transit workers
- China opposes EU scheme on carbon tax for airlines flying in Europe
- FAA to issue rules on pilot fatigue more than a year after deadline
- FAA to issue rules on pilot fatigue more than a year after deadline
- Boeing machinists accept 4 year contract extension
- Women-only taxis start plying on Malaysian roads
- Urgent drive to act on road safety in Africa
- U.S. officials worried about exploding shipping containers from Vietnam
- Loans
- Sarah Burton wins Designer of the Year at 2011 British Fashion Awards
- Gaudy Christmas sweaters making fashion comeback
- Latest Discounts
- Givenchy Handbags Sale
- 20% Off at GoJane Coupon Ends in 4 Days!
- Shopbob Major Mid Season Sales 30% to 70% Off
- Barbie gets inked in fashion makeover
- Sales 50% Off from Three Dots Detail
- Start A Fashion Business (Quick Guide)
- 7 for All Mankind Sales from Couture Candy
- Loans
- Crocs footwear moves into accessories and apparel
- Hottest 2012 Super Bowl souvenir is a hand-knit scarf
- Digital catwalk is the new fashion for couture shows
- Over-the-top sneakers are everywhere
- Let the returns and exchanges begin
- Hats that won’t leave you with helmet head
- Auctions sell Elizabeth Taylor’s jewels, Steve Jobs’ Apple contract for millions
- Keep your cashmere in shape for seasons to come
- Barneys devotes whole floor to world of Gaga
- Intimacy 2.0 dress becomes transparent as you flirt
- Personal loans
- Beward of Annual Fees on Credit Cards!
- Credit Card Rewards – Cash back or points, which is better?
- Never send money to relatives using Paypal
- Prevent Banks from Holding Checks
- Sending Money Abroad – Western Union Alternatives
- Rent to Own Furnishings – A Rip-Off?
- Are Canadian Housing Prices at the Top?
- Low Interest Credit Card Checks
- U.S. lawmakers aim to lure foreigners to buy American homes
- BoE pushes banks to cut bonuses, dividends to improve balance sheets
